June 21, 2013

Possessions as the Source of Violence: But What About MY Body?

A few eons ago, I started a blog series on the compatibility of self-defense/violence and Christianity.  This issue is incredibly important to me and the questions continues to haunt me.  As I described in the blog post prior to this one, I have taken martial arts for the purpose of self-defense for the last several years.  Why? People scare me.  I have friends who have been attacked and assaulted.  I have been approached by a stranger but was successfully able to deescalate the situation.  Statistics show that way too many women will get sexual assaulted in their lifetime, the vast majority before they hit 30 (and usually by someone known to them, but also sometimes by strangers).   So, both reason and experience point to idea that it is not too crazy to be watching your back and have a ready answer with what you would do the day the approach/attack happens.  The moral source that carries the greatest weight on this issue for me is Scripture.  But it is way more complex than most Christians admit it to be.  Not only is there a mixture of both violence as well as commands to love one another, but Scripture also does not address my moral question directly.  This creates a complex issue to wade through.


 Loving Your Enemy            

The majority (all) of Christians pick and chooses which biblical passages are their norm and leave out anything that may challenge their interpretation.  Nearly everything I have read on this topic falls into to extremes. For example, I was reading a blog recently entitled, “Love Your Enemies, Unless…” where the guy argues that there are no exceptions to Jesus’ command to love one’s enemies (Luke 6:32-36).  He argues that many Christians mistakenly view this command as an ideal that does not have relevance in the real world.  The blogger particularly emphasizes that when personal safety or the well-being of a loved one is at risk, Christians’ quickly dismiss concern for one’s enemy (which is a fair critique).  The guy contends that Jesus and the early church praised self-sacrifice, love of neighbor, and even died before lifting a finger to save themselves.  There are no references in the Bible to putting one’s own safety above the well-being of another person.  Many pacifists similarly quote examples from the Sermon on the Mount, which contains many of the passages that are said to argue for following the higher calling of loving others.  Hauerwas (probably one of the best known Christian pacifists out there with a lot of great questions on how to live life with a higher calling), for example, cites Matthew 5:43-48, as well as other pericopes from the Sermon on the Mount, to justify his argument for the ethical significance of Jesus and the foundation for his book, The Peaceable Kingdom. He writes, “For our possessions are the source of our violence.  Fearing that others desire what we have…we seek self-deceptive justifications that mire us in patterns of injustice which can be sustained only through coercion.  And of course we believe our most precious possession to be the self we have created, that we have chosen…What Jesus offers is a journey, an adventure.  Once undertaken, we discover that what we once held valuable, even the self, we no longer count as anything.”  Hauerwas argues that once we become disciples, we cannot count our personal safety as more valuable than another person’s well-being; the question of self-defense is no longer an issue when the self is viewed in this light. (But…it’s still an issue for me and I’m guessing most other people. So, why I think his statement is incredibly enlightening, I have some more ideas to wade through before I my “that’s it!” moment turns up. I would however, like us to keep it in mind as we continue, since there is a lot of truth to it.)


 The Grey Area: More Complications


            Both the blogger I mentioned and Hauerwas argue that Jesus’ command to love one’s enemy is a Scriptural ideal that is meant to be applied literally and in all circumstances.  When a person uses violence against another, both men would see this action as morally wrong.  However, it is extremely doubtful that Jesus meant all of his statements to be taken literally by his followers.  He often uses hyperbole to make a point, such as cutting off body parts in order to keep from sinning (Matt 5:27-30).  Few theologians argue for Christians to follow this command, despite the fact that it is in the same chapter as Christ’s command to love one’s enemies.  Additionally, does loving one’s enemy always necessitate a non-violent response?  Could one show love to a neighbor by stopping them from assaulting a woman?  Furthermore, passages from the Sermon on the Mount fail to deal with violence supported by Yahweh in the Old Testament and even by Jesus elsewhere in the Gospels.[1]  If Scripture includes a mixed assessment of violence, why should the Sermon on the Mount be more authoritative than other passages?[2]  Since self-defense against assault does not have an exact analogy in Scripture, the issue becomes a complex puzzle of different viewpoints from Scripture in addition to an attempt to apply passages to situations that were not necessarily written to address it.  Neither violence nor pacifism is upheld throughout all of Scripture.


 And that is where I am going to stop for today. (I know, cliffhanger!). The hope of the series of posts I am going to be putting up this week is that people will take a second to see where they fall on the issue of violence (I’ve heard one or two people talking recently about guns and gun control?) but then also on the issue of self-defense. Just to clarify, this has absolutely nothing to do with constitutional rights and national laws. I am concerned not about what the law allows me to do, but what can I ethically condone in my own life with an issue that terrifies me?
 Join me next time for how experience and stats are a second moral source to draw from! (This part is one everyone can relate to, I’m sure of it!)
 

[1] OT references include Nehemiah 1:14. References for Jesus’ support on violence, see Matt 26:51-53 and Luke 22:36.  A great book to check out is by Brendan F. Furnish, and Dwight Hervey Small, The Mounting Threat of Home Intruders: Weighing the Moral Option of Armed Self-Defense (Springfield, Ill.: C.C. Thomas, 1993), 107-125. Also, David Matson argues that modern translations of Luke 22:51 are portrayed as more pacifist than the Greek allows.  Any edition prior to WWII has a very different translation of the passage. One cannot help but wonder if this tragic war left its mark on the pages of our Bibles. David Matson, “Pacifist Jesus? The (Mis)Translation of Luke 22:51,” a soon to be published paper presented at the Stone-Campbell Journal Conference, Nashville, Tenn.: March 2013.[2]  Hauerwas rejects the depiction of war and violence in the OT as legitimately Christian.  


February 2, 2013

Kicking Butt and Taking...the Well-being of My Enemies into Account?


Several years ago, a good friend of mine was assaulted. I had an intense emotional response to the traumatic event; I became paranoid and developed an unhealthy fear of being assaulted as well. This fear became crippling and I did not know how to move past it.  To help, I joined a Kenpo Karate dojo, which is a mixed martial art focused exclusively on stopping as well as preventing any type of unwanted aggressive behavior. After a few years, I began to feel strong and capable. My sense of paralyzing fear was replaced with a healthy awareness of being able to avoid and, if needed, stop most types of assault.  However, as my fear subsided and my training increased, I began to be troubled by how comfortable with violence I had become. I spent numerous hours every week for years learning how to inflict pain on others in order to save myself or to save others. 


Statistics show that one in five women have been raped (or experienced an attempted rape), one in four women have been beaten, and one in six women have been stalked.  The odds are fair that at some point in my life, I will face an attacker and I will have to decide how to respond. In fact, I have been in several situations where I have had to deescalate situations with hostile males through aggressive but non-physical means (I am defining violence as forcing your will onto another person.  This can be anything from a threatening look, yelling inappropriate remarks, or to actually laying hands on a person with the intention to hurt them.  When I used aggressive but non-physical means to stop an attack, I yelled and threatened the person, which is the same behavior he had started doing to me. So, we both used aggressive, but non-physical violence in order to force our own will onto another person – in his case, he was attempting sexual assault. In my case, I coerced him into stopping his behavior and giving me time to get to safety. So, I won that confrontation by using similar techniques my "enemy" used on me). The next time I may not be lucky enough to be in a situation that I can stop through aggressive but non-physical means.


 As a Christian, I believe in the value of every human life. I also believe that sin has corrupted every person, some more so than others.  I believe the Sermon on the Mount has the clearest commands about loving one’s neighbor and loving one’s enemy. The question arises as to how to love others when someone may mean you harm. Do I have a right to protect myself? Do I have a responsibility to protect the vulnerable in my care (such as children)? Can loving one’s enemy include stopping your enemy from committing a terrible sin? If the answer is yes to any of these questions, then how much violence can one inflict (again, this includes everything from non-physical violence to the other extreme (perhaps, using a weapon to kill?)), while still following the mantra of loving one’s enemy?  Does one have the responsibility to inflict the minimum amount of damage in order to counter the attack?  My moral dilemma can be boiled down to this: As a female follower of Christ in a world where violence against women is common, how should I view/use violence (both physical and non-physical)? I will be spending my next few posts on this ethical quandary.


The first question which the priest and the Levite asked was: "If I stop and help this man, what will happen to me?" But...the good Samaritan reversed the question: "If I do not stop to help this man, what will happen to him?" - Martin Luther King Jr.


**As a side note, most people will think  there is no ethical quandary here. Those who see no ethical quandary have already made assumptions about the value of self-preservation being more important than the well-being of another person, even an enemy. I am not necessarily disagreeing with this yet. I am just taking a deep breath and looking at the whole issue of using violence to stop violence. Instead of reacting from a place of fear (which is what I have been doing for years and continue to do), I would like to look at this issue and figure out where my boundaries lay. 

January 6, 2013

The Post Where I Admit I Love Rachael Evans

For the last few years, I have had quite a few friends who are crazy about Rachael Evans (she's a Christian blogger and author). I have read a few of her posts, but I just could not see what all the fuss was about. I did like her more than most conservative Christian women who reflect on what it means to be a Christian woman, but that isn't saying much since I avoid those authors like the plague.  So, when I was challenged to read her book and write a reflection on it, I started it with low expectations. 


Two pages into the book, I realized I was completely wrong about Evans.  As I read more, Jon asked me how I liked it...and I had to humbly admit that I loved it. It is one of the best reflections on the difficulty of being a woman in a male-dominated religion and how to live out your calling when most of your tradition gives no encouragement to it. Evans does not walk away from her religion or her tradition, but she freely questions it and the restrictions that are put on women in the name of being "biblical."  The truth is, when you read the Bible so narrowly, you loose the fact that God is a great and magnificent God who can do anything through anyone. So what has God inspired me to do? What do I feel a calling towards? What is it that burns like a fire in my bones? Many of us know but are too afraid to do it. I know I am. And it is a lot of work, time, effort, and makes me feel like a target. Once I began to think outside of the box and reject the many restrictions put on me, it changed everything for me.


One issue I do suffer from is bitterness. I try to keep it at bay, but every time someones makes a comment about my gender, it rises to the surface. I don't want to be bitter. I don't want to be angry at my brothers and sisters. But it is hard since it happens continuously, whether people mean it or not. This is another reason I love Evans. She laughs about the ridiculousness of these constraints. I read one review by a man who thinks she doesn't take the Bible serious enough. I would argue just the opposite. She takes the Bible quite seriously. She just finds so many interpretations about "biblical gender roles" to be silly. 

 

Reading through her book is like sitting with a friend who is going through all the same issues, but comes through them without bitterness and with a mischievous smile on her face. I applaud her for being able to find freedom and joy in being a woman and being a Christian. 

I want more than anything to become a New Testament Professor.  Jon and I had the privilege to go teach a class in the Philippines several years ago. And I loved it! Teaching and traveling - that's about as good as it gets!

December 31, 2012

Proto-Narnian Theology


The story of the incarnation, from beginning to end, is inexplicably marvelous and astonishing.  Once a year we celebrate the coming of the divine into the world. We remember that the word became flesh – that God wrapped himself in human skin and became a vulnerable infant.  We celebrate the coming of the Son into the world with presents, Christmas lights, decorating trees, family gatherings, and lots of food.  With Christmas over, we now take down the lights, exchange the ugly sweaters we received as gifts, and begin to have life get back to normal.  But the birth of Christ is just the beginning of the story of the incarnation.  The story doesn't end there! The ramifications of Christ’s birth and death are felt to this day.  We gather together every week to remember the sacrifice Christ made on our behalf.  It didn't end in a tomb. Christ rose and the world was forever changed! Weekly, during communion, we focus on the other end of the incarnation– Jesus’ death and resurrection.


Leo the Great preached, “Truly wondrous is the whole chronicle of the incarnation. From the time when Christ came, slavery ended, the devil is thwarted, demons take to flight, the power of death is broken, paradise is unlocked, the curse is taken away, sin is removed from us, error is driven out, truth has been brought back, and the speech of love begins to spread.  A heavenly way of life has been implanted on the earth.” 



(This has the C.S. Lewis' Narnia written all over it! Or, at least, that was the first thing I thought of!)


As New Year approaches and we make our resolutions, let us strive to live as men and women who have been freed from bondage – without fear of death, with the key to paradise, and participating in this heavenly way of life that Jesus established for us. We live a life with the ethics, trust, and love of the next world while living in this world. Once we accept the sacrifice Christ made for us, our lives should begin to reflect the exciting and world-shattering words spoken long ago by Leo the Great.   May our lives be a display of continual praise and thanks for this event, not just at Christmas and Easter, but at every moment of our lives, with every breath we take, and with every word we speak.  Our time of slavery has ended,  Satan has been defeated, death is no longer something to be feared, the door to paradise has been thrown open wide, our sins are forgiven and forgotten, the curse is broken, truth is now a way of life, and we now speak the language of love. Instead of living in darkness, Jesus came to be a light and rid our lives of darkness.  Help us to not love darkness but to bask in the light.
     

November 25, 2012

When I was Ordained, I Wore a Girly Dress


Not everyone understands the pressure of gender expectations in a field dominated by the opposite sex. It is difficult to balance wanting to be accepted and taken seriously with being yourself.  I have been told not to appear too feminine when I speak in front of a church. To those who think this, I might as well tell you that I will do the exact opposite. I will dress appropriately, of course, but I will embrace who God has made me and not attempt to hide it. I am a woman. And I'm not ashamed of it. I wear bright and girly dresses, colorful makeup, and adorn my hair with flowers.  I can speak the Word while wearing red lipstick. I can stand and preach just as well in high heels. I can care for others all the better in my girly dress because I feel free and can be myself, not hiding who I am under a mask others have asked me to wear. Here is a poem that I absolutely love. It expresses this problem, the pain, and the joy better than I can. It is called "When I am Ordained, I Shall Purple." And as you can see below, I did exactly that.


 ______________________________________

When I am Ordained, I shall wear Purple

by Mia Smith
When I am ordained, I shall wear purple
with killer heels and bright red lipstick
And I shall go round preaching from the Bible

The liberating truth that Jesus calls women
and tell those who say otherwise that it is they,
not I, who are bad theologians. I shall sit down with fellow clergy when we are tired of fighting for equality
and going the extra mile with grace when we are put down,
And we will make up for it:
by encouraging one another as Scripture says,
and praying for those who abuse us,
and rejoicing that we are suffering
(but just a little bit) for Jesus,
And we might even eat some chocolate. I will adopt the ordination name “Junia”,
and remind those who object,
that there may be a boy named Sue somewhere in the world,
but there probably isn’t.


But now we must face the world,
Who think we are traitors to our sex
For working for the Church
And face our brothers and sisters who think
We are being unbiblical
And face those in our Churches
who have failed to notice the pain this week has brought.
And we will go in the strength of Christ.
We will not turn our backs on our calling
Because God is not finished with the Church,
And He is faithful. But maybe I ought to practice a little now?
So people who know me are not too shocked and surprised
When suddenly I am ordained, and start to wear purple.

November 23, 2012

Living Like a Lily of the Field: Part II


It is a difficult discipline not to buy things and own things in a society that is all about having more and more. Here are some tips I have found and some practices I am working on. 1) Don’t go to the mall.  Casually window-shopping or even just walking through my favorite stores does nothing but convince me that I need more.  Advertising really is pretty convincing, isn’t it?  I love fashion, for example. When I go to the mall, I see all the things I would love to have. But the cycle never breaks. There never seems to be a point where I have enough clothes or dress well enough. So I just avoid malls altogether.  Even going to Target or going to the grocery store can be fraught with these perils. It is essential to be very intentional when going anywhere you spend your money (have a budget and a list in hand!).  Additionally, your philosophy of money and material possession needs to be continually flushed out. Aristotle said that the unexamined life is not worth living.  Take some time to examine your relationship to your possessions, to money, and set goals for yourself.  It can be anything from a simple budget to a vow of poverty, but making a conscious decision is indispensable.  2) Make repurposing and recycling a lifestyle.  Instead of buying new clothes, for example, I swap with friends, shop at garage sales and thrift stores, or refashion items I already own but haven’t worn in a while.  This is a great practice because it also teaches patience. Often, I have to wait for a while until I can cross something off my list. Recently, I was looking for curtain. It took a month of stopping at garage sales before I found some. My need for instant gratification has been very challenged! 3) Find great ways to put your money to use that does not involve buying more things.  I was literally struck dumb a few weeks ago when a couple handed me a check for several hundred dollars for groceries and said to expect another one next month.  I told them that this was way too much money to just be handing out to people! My friend responded that she had disciplined herself to not want things. She said, “Why would I buy some more stuff when I can help you guys buy groceries or support a missionary?” Well, that certainly does put things in perspective! Why should I spend a small fortune keeping up with the latest trends when I can give micro-loans to women in the Middle East or pay to send women to school in Afghanistan? Moreover, what if that small fortune I was spending on clothing was contributing to lining the pockets of sweatshop owners, destroying the environment (and again, hurting the poor), and weighing me down spiritually?  This perspective makes choices much easier! 4) Find heroes, authors, and friends who inspire you to do more and reach your full potential.  Mother Teresa, Shane Claiborne, and Gandhi are some people I continually look to for inspiration on these issues.  I also have friends who are very serious about these issues, like my husband and many friends.
            In light of all these reasons, I decided to make up a new tradition for me, my family, and my future family to follow. Instead of being thankful for all the things I have on one day and then the next spending tons of money on things I was fine without the day before, I am going to find as many things in my house to get rid of as I can. Not only for the sake of myself but also for the sake of others.  I can then donate these items or give them to people who I know are struggling or need something. This is my new Black Friday tradition, which is the next step up from the “buy nothing day” I usually celebrate. This is a healthier and more appropriate way to spend the day after Thanksgiving! It is a sad symptom of our culture when you see the news covering the thousands of people who have been camping out for days, who trample fellow human beings, and the usual report of injuries and even death by the end of the day. I hope this tradition catches on. I think it would be better for everyone.
            Shane Claiborne in the book Red Letter Christians (which I highly recommend) retells the biblical story commonly referred to as the Rich Man and Lazarus. He pointed out how the walls and gates the rich man built to keep people like Lazarus at bay not only hurt the poor but it also hurt the rich man. The poor man suffered from lack of food, shelter, care, etc. but the rich man also suffered, even though he does not realize it until the end of the story.  The walls he built kept him away from the people he needed to be in community with in order to be in true communion with God. Having too many possession and holding on to them too tightly ruined his life. In fact, in the story he asks if Lazarus can go and warn his brother about their lifestyle and that it needs to be changed because it is keeping them from God and from others.  Possessions and the love of those possessions are what broke the two greatest commandments: love God and love your neighbor.  I know that few people would identify themselves with the rich man in this story.  One of the jarring parts of the story, however, is that the rich man himself was shocked at these accusations. He believed he was following God’s commands. How many of us are actually the rich man in this story? Probably more of us than would care to admit.

I will leave off with this final paragraph from Red Letter Revolution: “In John 10: 10, Jesus says he has come to give us life to the fullest, not guilt to the fullest. So I’m interested in that life— and so are a lot of other folks— because we often settle for something far short of life to the fullest. We opt for survival, security, and comfort rather than the cross and suffering love of Jesus. We choose the American dream instead of the gospel dream. But the freest people I know are the folks who have learned to live like the lilies and the sparrows. Once a reporter said to Mother Teresa that he couldn’t do what she did if he was paid a million dollars. She answered, “Yes, for a million dollars I wouldn’t do it either.” I think Jesus is showing us that there is a pearl, a prize, worth leaving everything for. So it’s not about what you’ve left, but it’s about what you’ve found.”

Living like a Lily of the Field: Part I


This month I have been posting a different thing I am thankful for each day on Facebook.  Even on bad days, it was a wonderful practice to stop and think of one thing that brought me true joy and happiness. While reviewing that list, I realized not a single one on my list was any possession I owned.  A summary of my list: my husband, family, friends, church community, and my dog. One of my all-time favorite reads is Mother Teresa’s A Simple Path.  She says that the opposite is in fact true – the more “things” you have, the unhappier you are."When you don't have anything, then you have everything."  I’m going to agree with her on this one.  
            Over the last few years, I have been moving steadily through different phases in order to achieve a more simplistic lifestyle.  For a while now I have been going through the “buy only used items” stage (except for things like toothbrushes…).  There have been a couple of reasons for it. First, since my husband and I are both in grad school full time, we make next to nothing.  Grad school is a great way to cut your spending habits.  Second, I have become increasingly concerned about the ecological impact the American standard of living is having on the world (for goodness sakes, we use a quarter of the world’s resources and make up only 4% of the world’s population).  Besides being concerned with the environment for its own sake, the people who will be most affected by these types of decisions are the poor – in this country and all over the world.  Third, the more information I have about where most of my stuff comes from, the heavier it sits on my conscious.  I should not and cannot help sustain large populations of people (especially children!) who are put into dangerous and terrible situations in sweatshops to make a shirt for me (Mother Teresa says,"When a poor person dies of hunger, it has not happened because God did not take care of him or her. It has happened because neither you nor I wanted to give that person what he or she needed."). Fourth, the money can be put to better use than buying another thing I don’t need. There are quite a few more, but these are some of the major reasons I am working on scaling back my lifestyle.
            I think some of my heroes like Mother Teresa were on to something with their vow of poverty.  An example that always jumps to my mind when I think of simplicity is a trip my friend and I took a few years ago. We were going to be gone for several weeks, so I packed my suitcase to the brim. It was exhausting lugging around a huge suitcase, digging through tons of things to find my toothbrush, and I couldn’t help but scatter things everywhere as I tried to find something in my bag.  I didn’t think too much about it because that is just simply how a person travels.  One day, though, we filled a backpack each with a single change of clothes and a few basic things. We locked our suitcases in a storage room at a hostel, and we took off to go exploring. We rented mopeds and just went wherever the wind would take us. To my dying day one of my favorite images will be my friend on her moped in front of me with her backpack on, with the Mediterranean Sea on one side and tall hills topped with ancient ruins on the other. We were gone for a few days and one of the best parts of that trip was how little stuff we had. We could go and do what we wanted because of how little held us down.  When I think of living a life free of clutter, useless items, and freedom, this is the image my mind conjures, not a life that is somehow lessened because I own fewer material possessions.